Sampling Plans for Plant Bugs – Challenges of Monitoring Aggregated Pest Populations

As we move toward squaring and bloom stages, it is essential to plan plant bug scouting strategies depending on crop development. Our recommended thresholds for squaring and bloom-stage cotton provide a recommended number of stops per field (scouting information can be found on the Tarnished Plant Bugs Article).

In that recommendation, we highlight the tendency of adult plant bugs to aggregate in pockets along field edges. These field-scale recommendations work well, but there is still some uncertainty about the similarity among fields and which land-use factors are related to higher plant bug numbers.

To tackle this problem cotton entomologists surveyed 120 fields across the southeastern USA. We sampled cotton at square and again at bloom at four locations within each field (Fig. 1).

Map of sampled cotton fields in southeastern US with inset field sampling layout and crop legend
Figure 1. (A) 120 commercial cotton fields sampled across the southeastern USA in 2019 and 2020. (B) Land use information around fields. (C) Four 25 sweep net sampling units and two drop cloth (1.5 row-m) units per quadrant for sweep net and drop cloth sampling, respectively (figure from Dorman et al. 2022).
Key Findings:
  • We found that plant bugs counts were most variable with and among fields. In other words, we found many instances of high and low counts within individual fields. In addition, fields in a given area had very different levels of pressure.
  • This finding tells us that thorough scouting is necessary 1) across the field, and 2) among fields in a growing area.
  • The amount of double-cropped wheat/soybean and the total amount of ag land surrounding our cotton fields was the best predictor of plant bug counts.
  • We found that more sweep samples & drops improved our estimate of plant bug populations.

What do these results mean for plant bug scouting in 2022?
  • Assuming a single field is representative of cotton on a farm or region is not a good idea
  • We have a significant amount of double-crop wheat/beans in some cotton growing areas. Ensure susceptible cotton near grain is scouted thoroughly.
  • Take enough samples. We recommend 6-10 per field. Ensure these samples are distributed across the field to minimize chances of missing a pocket of plant bugs.
We thank all the researchers that contributed to this work. The full paper can be found on MDPI.