March Is Burndown Time (York & Collins)

— Written By

Much of NC’s cotton is grown in no-till or strip-till systems and therefore requires a preplant burndown treatment to control winter weeds and/or cover crops.  Mid-March through the first week in April is generally the ideal time for burndown applications.

Numerous species of winter annual weeds can be found. Some of the more common species include the following:

1. Annual bluegrass1. Annual bluegrass

2. Italian ryegrass

2. Italian ryegrass

3. Henbit

3. Henbit

4. Purple deadnettle

4. Purple deadnettle

5. Common chickweed

5. Common chickweed

6. Mouseear chickweed

6. Mouseear chickweed

7. Cutleaf eveningprimrose

7. Cutleaf eveningprimrose

8. Cudweed

8. Cudweed

9. Mouseear cress

9. Mouseear cress

10. Carolina geranium

10. Carolina geranium

11. Field pansy

11. Field pansy

12. Wild radish

12. Wild radish

13. Virginia pepperweed

13. Virginia pepperweed

14. Knawel

14. Knawel

15. Oldfield toadflax

15. Oldfield toadflax

16. Corn spurry

16. Corn spurry

17. Horseweed

17 Horseweed

18. Horseweed

18 Horseweed

Most winter weeds are controlled by glyphosate. However, there are some exceptions, and it is for these exceptions that we include another herbicide with the glyphosate. That other herbicide is typically 2,4-D although dicamba (Clarity, others), thifensulfuron + tribenuron (FirstShot, Harmony Extra, others), rimsulfuron + thifensulfuron (Leadoff, others), saflufenacil (Sharpen), carfentrazone (Aim), and pyraflufen (ET) are also options. Flumioxazin (Valor, others) is often included for residual control. Aim or ET will hasten burndown of weeds but in the long run, they typically do not improve control.

Application rates and other information on burndown herbicides can be found in the 2016 Cotton Information publication (http://content.ces.ncsu.edu/cotton-information/weed-management-in-cotton).  Table 1. below gives the efficacy ratings for various burndown treatments on our more common weeds.

Glyphosate vs Paraquat. Paraquat is an alternative to glyphosate. However, glyphosate is typically more economical and is often more effective on most species. The exceptions are Carolina geranium (picture 10) and field pansy (picture 11); paraquat is more effective than glyphosate on these species. Carolina geranium is usually adequately controlled by glyphosate + dicamba, glyphosate + rimsulfuron + thifensulfuron, and glyphosate + thifensulfuron + tribenuron.  No glyphosate combinations work well on field pansy, and paraquat or paraquat + diuron remain the best options. Diuron added to paraquat will boost control compared with paraquat alone.

Horseweed. Horseweed (picture 17, picture 18), also called marestail, was once controlled well by glyphosate. However, glyphosate-resistant horseweed is now widespread in the Coastal Plain and is beginning to make an appearance in the Piedmont. Burndown combinations of glyphosate + 2,4-D + flumioxazin (Valor, others) or glyphosate + dicamba (Clarity, others) + flumioxazin have been our standard recommendations. The suggested rates of 2,4-D or Clarity are 2 pt/acre and ½ pt/acre, respectively. This rate of 2,4-D is higher than needed for other weeds but typically is more consistently effective than lower rates. Dicamba may be more effective than 2,4-D, especially with later applications when the weeds are beginning to shoot up. Glyphosate plus Sharpen is also an effective treatment for horseweed although the longer waiting period between application and planting for Sharpen is problematic for some growers.

Most horseweed emerges in the fall. Emergence declines or ceases in the winter but additional emergence can occur in April and May. For this reason, we suggest a residual herbicide (typically Valor) as part of the burndown to control later-emerging horseweed. Valor also gives some residual control of other weeds, Palmer amaranth in particular, going into the growing season.

Wild Radish.  This species (picture 12) is often not adequately controlled by glyphosate alone, especially if it attains much size. 2,4-D is the preferred material to mix with glyphosate for radish control although glyphosate + dicamba should also be adequately effective.

Italian Ryegrass. Glyphosate has long been the preferred herbicide to burndown ryegrass (picture 2). However, we are beginning to see instances of glyphosate-resistant ryegrass, especially in the Piedmont. Where one expects resistance in ryegrass, the alternative approach is paraquat applied twice. One application of paraquat is usually not adequate whereas two applications, two or more weeks apart, typically work well. Diuron added with the first application may boost control.

Cover Crops. Glyphosate is the material of choice to kill wheat or rye cover crops. If clover or vetch is mixed with the wheat or rye, one needs to include dicamba or 2,4-D with the glyphosate. Vetch is adequately controlled by either 2,4-D or dicamba whereas dicamba is the better material on clover.

One of the goals of a cover crop, in addition to erosion protection, is suppression of summer weeds and moisture conservation. Greater weed suppression and moisture conservation will be obtained with greater biomass produced by the cover crops. Hence, growers may want to allow the cover crop to grow later into the spring to produce more biomass. Even so, it is still a good idea to kill the cover crop a couple weeks ahead of planting to avoid excessive moisture depletion by the cover crop. A good stand of cover crop usually suppresses winter weeds well. However, if the wheat or rye cover crop is thin and winter broadleaf weeds are present, especially horseweed, one can apply 2,4-D or dicamba in March and allow the cover crop to continue to grow before terminating it later with glyphosate.

Waiting periods. There is no waiting period between application of Aim or ET and cotton planting. Labels for thifensulfuron + tribenuron products (FirstShot, Harmony Extra, others) specify a 14-day interval between application and cotton planting. Labels for dicamba-containing products (Clarity, others) specify accumulation of 1 inch of rainfall followed by a 21-day waiting interval. Rimsulfuron + thifensulfuron (Leadoff, others) requires a 30-day waiting period. Labels for products containing 2,4-D specify a 30-day interval between application and cotton planting although growers have learned that the intervals can easily be shortened to 14 days if soil moisture is good.

Table 1. Efficacy ratings for burndown treatments

Written By

Dr. Guy CollinsExtension Cotton Specialist (252) 578-7719 guy_collins@ncsu.eduCrop and Soil Sciences - NC State University

Contributing Specialist

Dr. Alan YorkNamed Professor Emeritus alan_york@ncsu.eduCrop and Soil Sciences - NC State University
Posted on Mar 7, 2016
Was the information on this page helpful? Yes check No close
This page can also be accessed from: go.ncsu.edu/readext?401199